Grade Levels, Standards and Benchmarks

From our FAQ: Getting Started:

There are standard curricula and grade-level goals available:

• Advice on Standards
• Debate about Standards
• New York City Board of Ed. Standards
• New York State Education Dept. Standards
• National Standards

But please don't let yourself be limited by standardized goals. The real answer to this question is that your child will tell you. You just have to listen closely. If your child is bored, then you should increase the level of the material. If your child is confused or overwhelmed, you should lower the level of the material. Like most people, you should expect your child to be more ahead in some things than in others. Also, not every school (nor every home) sets the same standards. If you were to compare Harvard University with, say South Dakota Community College (a name I just made up), although they both might be colleges, well, you know that they wouldn't be the same. So don't limit yourself to standard expectations. Instead, change the rules! Why not decide within your own family, teacher and student together, what the expectations and goals will be? Set goals that you find attainable, and set standards that excite you!

Laurie is also available for personal curriculum consultation

Advice on Standards

• Goals for First Grade: Early Reading and Writing
• At About.com, you can go to their Typical Course of Study for PreK-12: scroll down and click on any grade from Preschool to 12 to get a complete list (taken from the World Book Encyclopedia) of a typical course of study for that grade.
• One popular source for homeschooling K-8 curriculum is the Core Knowledge Series by E.D. Hirsch, Jr., What Your nth Grader Needs to Know: Fundamentals of a Good nth Grade Education. View the table of contents to see at a glance a full year curriculum for that grade.

Debate about Standards

• Read the The New K-12 Standards Debate and Ratatat, Sissy, Bay State Boom: Obama Whacks K-12 Standards from the National Association of Scholars
• Stop National Standards is an organization of highly respected educators fighting standardization in our schools, with a Call to Action.

New York City Board of Ed. Standards

• New York City Learning Standards
• New York City Peformance Standards. [note: this website seems to be in a state of chaos, and many links do not work.] Literacy, Language Arts, Mathematics, Science and Applied Learning.

New York State Education Dept. Standards

For Arts; Career Development and Occupational Studies; English Language Arts; Health, Physical Education, and Family Consumer Sciences; Languages Other Than English, Including American Sign Language; Mathematics; Science and Technology; and Social Studies, see their

• Curriculum, Instruction & Instructional Technology
• Learning Standards of New York State
• New York State Learning Standards and Core Curriculum

See also the Latest News on ELA, Mathematics, and Grades 3-8 Testing, and their sample tests for Language Arts and Elementary/Intermediate Tests and Regents Examinations.

National Standards

The National standards for English and math were recently updated and made more concise and easier to understand. They are still full of educators' double-speak, and offer suggestions that do not need to be followed exactly. For example, in English, to "cite a textual example" or "analyze" a story's "overall structure" can deaden the literary experience if taken too seriously. I suggest that "discuss" could be substituted for "analyze" and a freer approach could be taken.

As another example, the suggested reading (for grades 6-12, this is on page 58) includes Macbeth as the only Shakespeare play. At home, my son and I read a Shakespeare play every year (sometimes more than one), and Macbeth was far from our favorite. In fact, my son complained that the only part worth reading was Lady Macbeth, and Macbeth, the title character, was a total wimp. I suggest starting with a Shakespearean comedy, such as A Midsummer Night's Dream or Much Ado About Nothing, and then reading a tragedy, perhaps Romeo & Juliet or Hamlet. Similarly, you do not need to introduce yourself to John Steinbeck with his greatest and longest literary work, The Grapes of Wrath. His other novels, such as Tortilla Flat or Cannery Row, will be more easily accessible to a young teen, and possibly even more enjoyable depending on the personality of the reader.

See the Common Core State Standards Initiative website for useful links and tips.

• Arts: Standards for Dance, Music Theater, Visual Arts
• Civics: Standards for Civics from the Center for Civic Education.
• History: National Standards for History Basic Edition, 1996
• Language Arts - English:
  • Common Core: English Language Arts(pdf format)
  • Standards for the English Language Arts
• Language Arts - Foreign Languages: National Standards for Language Education
• Math:
  • Common Core: Math Standards (pdf format)
  • Standards, National Council of Teachers of Mathematics
• Phys. Ed.: National Standards for Physical Education
• Science: National Science Education Standards
• Social Studies: Curriculum Standards for Social Studies
• Technology: National Educational Technology Standards